Showing posts with label proposals. Show all posts
Showing posts with label proposals. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

The Habit of Excellence

Editor's Note: A habit to ponder for the New Year. The Seven Habits series and Industry Speaks posting will resume in January 2014.

Recently I read a proposal that, like most, had a section written about the firm’s QA/QC procedures. It was eloquent. It highlighted the QA/QC director, and a QA/QC process. There was just one problem ... it wasn’t true!

While the narrative was well written, it was fiction, describing a theoretical quality control process the firm would go through if they had time. The truth is the QA/QC director (by his own admission) often doesn’t have time to do quality control. Tight fees, even tighter deadlines, insufficient staff and multiple responsibilities make it all but impossible. The drawings are instead checked hastily by the project manager as the clock ticks toward the deadline or as someone frantically calls to ask for an extension.

I’m sad to say I haven’t seen an excellent QA/QC process recently. That doesn’t mean they don’t exist. Those I recall from ages ago were in smaller firms where excellence was a core value in the firm’s operations. They were successful. But, in smaller (niche) firms, there are no QA/QC directors. Everyone does everything.

The process described in that proposal wasn’t bad. It just failed to recognize the realities of a working architectural practice. As an industry, we must develop a way to bring quality assurance and control to the core of the design process on a consistent basis — not when we have time, or when the client is willing to pay for it — but all of the time. Clients expect and demand no less, and so should we as representatives of this profession.

Karen Compton, CPSM. Karen Compton is principal of A3K Consulting (Glendale, CA), a business development and strategic planning firm specializing in the architecture, engineering and construction industries. Ms. Compton is also the founder of Industry Speaks™, a web-based business-to-business portal that connects AEC firms with experienced consultants, provides peer reviews of consultants, reports on key industry trends, and publishes expert reviews of professional courses and books. Contact her at kcompton@a3kconsulting.com.

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Industry Speaks Review: aecKnowledge Course on Public Design Opportunities for Small Firms

Excerpt: "This course will provide you with meaningful insights on how to seek public design work and be successful with your efforts. The insights are offered directly from panelists who have had many years of experience in qualifying and selecting architects for public facilities."

Armando Gonzalez, FAIA, has reviewed Growing a Small Firm: Public Design Opportunities for Industry Speaks. Read the full review here.

Thursday, June 13, 2013

All Market Sectors Are Not Created Equal

A client of ours recently boasted that they are in 13 market sectors (within a six-person firm). The bottom line didn’t reflect 13 sectors, though, because not all market sectors performed equally well. For example, the tenant improvement market they serviced (engineering) lost money for any project less than $150K in fee. Conversely, the engineering projects they did for schools were not only profitable, but they had the right team and resources to do the work. In between the TI work and the schools work was every permutation one could imagine—somewhat profitable ran by junior staff to reasonably profitable with a mix of managers and staff.

I asked if the firm pursued new business equally across all of the market sectors. The answer was yes. Then my question was, “Why?” Let’s assume it costs $10,000 to pursue one proposal in each sector. Let’s also assume that in a year, the firm proposes on one opportunity in each sector: that’s $130,000. If 1/3 of the sectors perform marginally to poor, that means $39,000 a year is spent in the pursuit of work that under performs. Not only do they lose money on that work, but the return on investment for the business development dollars expended is also poor.

What happens if they abandon the pursuit of those marginal and poor performing sectors? Well, proposal costs go down to $91,000 per year, and the business development return on investment increases (with ROI defined as the net fee earned divided by the cost of the pursuit).

Before you think that all market sectors are created equal, do the math. Understand the sectors that provide the highest levels of client satisfaction, define the size of projects that tend to make or lose money, define staff experience relative to the size and complexity of work and then be prepared to modify your pursuit strategy accordingly.

We can all agree that every dollar is equally hard to make, but all market sectors are not created equal!

Karen Compton, CPSM. Karen Compton is principal of A3K Consulting (Glendale, CA), a business development and strategic planning firm specializing in the architecture, engineering and construction industries. Ms. Compton is also the founder of Industry Speaks™, a web-based business-to-business portal that connects AEC firms with experienced consultants, provides peer reviews of consultants, reports on key industry trends, and publishes expert reviews of professional courses and books. Contact her at kcompton@a3kconsulting.com.

Thursday, May 23, 2013

We Came in 19th Out of 20!

A client of ours submitted a proposal for the “AnyCity” small community library. They weren’t shortlisted, and in fact came in 19th out of 20. A few months later, when the firm retained us, I asked to look at the submission. My conclusion: every “Don’t” they “Did.”
  1. They responded to a blind solicitation. They pulled the RFP off of a list serve, decided they “met the qualifications” and submitted. This rarely works. In today’s competitive environment, there are a number of firms that “meet the criteria.” Clients like AnyCity mitigate their risk by selecting firms they know, or have a relationship with. That brings me to the second problem:
  2. They had no relationship to AnyCity. That meant that in their proposal they could not define what made them uniquely qualified in their understanding of AnyCity’s library needs or its issues and concerns. Most clients don’t want to take a risk on a firm that they don’t know; let alone on one that doesn’t know them.
  3. They didn’t have relevant project experience.Yes, they had done a library project before, but that was a TI of a smaller library, not a new building. Without starting advantages, they couldn’t compete against larger multi-office firms with expansive portfolios bottom feeding for smaller projects. They needed to show a strong correlation to work they had completed. It’s a tough sell, especially if you don’t know the client.
  4. The visual quality was abominable. There, I said it. In the age of more work and less time, clients want to be entertained. They want to be swept up into the proposal that you’ve presented for their reviewing pleasure—especially since that viewing pleasure is taking place more and more on their “off time.” Proposals don’t need to be glossy covered books, but their graphic layout and design must engage the reader. Getting your document read is step one. Taking the headers of the solicitation and responding with dense, narrative paragraphs is not a winning approach.
These types of mistakes are costly and avoidable: costly in the sense that to produce the proposal cost about $10K in manpower; avoidable in the sense that the same $10K can and should be invested in pre-selling to clients. That $10K investment in pre-selling would automatically eliminate three of the four mistakes made above!

Karen Compton, CPSM. Karen Compton is principal of A3K Consulting (Glendale, CA), a business development and strategic planning firm specializing in the architecture, engineering and construction industries. Ms. Compton is also the founder of Industry Speaks™, a web-based business-to-business portal that connects AEC firms with experienced consultants, provides peer reviews of consultants, reports on key industry trends, and publishes expert reviews of professional courses and books. Contact her at kcompton@a3kconsulting.com.

Thursday, March 29, 2012

Strategically Position Your Firm to Get More Work


Most firms are actually very good at answering all of the questions clients pose in their RFPs.  Unfortunately, that isn’t enough to win proposals on a consistent basis.  You must go two steps further In order to do that.  First, you need to clearly identify the critical, make-it-hard-to-sleep-at-night challenges facing the client for the project at hand.  Then, you must demonstrate how you are going to address those scary challenges differently and better than anyone else.  That hugely effective strategy is built upon strategic positioning.

As you address each of the RFP questions, you need to connect your answer to the bigger picture, which is pounding home how you are going to solve the client’s problems.  (Are you starting to notice a theme here?)  You also need to keep in mind how each of your competitors is likely to answer that same question.  What strengths of theirs will they tout?  What weaknesses of yours will they try to exploit?  Most importantly, how can you answer this question in a way that demonstrates how you will address the critical challenges better than anyone else?  Keep in mind it isn’t even enough to simply address those challenges.  You need to address them in a way that is different and better than everyone else.

You can’t strategically position your firm, of course, if you don’t know all you possibly can about each of your competitors.  (Too many firms don’t even know who their competitors are as they pursue proposal opportunities.)  It is also critical to start with a clear-eyed assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of your own firm—through your client’s eyes, not your own.  Then do the same kind of brutally honest assessment for each of your competitors.  Know their strengths and weaknesses almost as well as you know your own.  These assessments take real courage and honesty.  Most firms with whom I have worked have an impression of their own firm and the competition that is not at all consistent with what their clients see.

That is the start of strategic positioning.  In future blogs, I will discuss what to do with this knowledge and how to strategically position your firm in a variety of competitive scenarios.  Here is some homework to do in the meantime:  Consider Apple and Southwest Airlines.  How do these strategic geniuses position themselves against their competition?

Ken Tichacek, Founding Principal